EDITIONOctober 2026
Breaking
Grading FinTwit against the tape
The Accountability Desk · October 2026 edition

Now You Can Tell Them Apart

Measured on whether a call reached its target before its stop, 126 of 229 graded accounts clear the line chance alone would set — under the close-price measure we used until this edition, it was 7 of 229. 27 accounts entered the top 100 this month; 27 dropped out. When the S&P 500 rose, FinTwit hit 62%; when it fell, 61%. The gap is real but modest — less of this record is market beta than the returns alone suggest.

What moved this month
Ranked roster−13
01Who Clears the Bar229 graded accounts
Clear the chance line
55.0%
126 of 229. Under the old measure, 7 of 229.
Top decile vs chance
+7.7 pts
69.2% against a 61.5% bar.
Median vs chance
+0.6 pts−1.5 pts
The typical account is above the line.
Top decile69.2%
Median62.2%
Bottom decile56.1%

A “decile” is just a tenth of the field: the best tenth, the middle, and the worst. A hit is a call that reached its target before its stop, inside 7 days. The target scales with each ticker's volatility, +5% against −8% on most names and tighter on steady ones. Because the stop sits further out than the target, chance alone lands near 61.5% — so that, not 50%, is the line to read these against.

The Tape
NVDA72.6%GOOG72.7%MSFT81.3%AMZN76.5%TSLA84.1%PLTR76.5%BTC85.5%SPCX71.1%HOOD50.0%MRNA48.9%COHR49.3%DRAM53.1%SNOW42.1%WDC44.8%ALAB37.4%NOK47.4%NVDA72.6%GOOG72.7%MSFT81.3%AMZN76.5%TSLA84.1%PLTR76.5%BTC85.5%SPCX71.1%HOOD50.0%MRNA48.9%COHR49.3%DRAM53.1%SNOW42.1%WDC44.8%ALAB37.4%NOK47.4%

Crossing the wire: the names the crowd talked about most, and how often calls on them landed.

Volume state
Where the tape got loud
Resolved 30d tape
Resolved calls
—
Calls with a 30-day outcome in this edition.
Ranked field
229
Accounts with enough history to grade.
Buy pressure
—
Share of calls that leaned bullish.
Peak crowd
NVDA
234 distinct callers
Most crowded tickers
NVDA logoNVDA
234 callers
GOOG logoGOOG
177 callers
MSFT logoMSFT
167 callers
AMZN logoAMZN
165 callers
02What Separates Them7d hit % · vs chance

The sharpest split on this page isn't audience size and it isn't conviction — it's whether someone was calling a ticker they already know. Accounts with a per-ticker score of 70 or better hit 83% on that ticker; everyone else, 63%.

Specialists
83.3%
Generalists
63.4%

One axis, four different questions — expertise, asset class, company size. It is a summary, not a like-for-like ranking; the tables below cut each one on its own. The line is 61.5%, what chance alone would reach.

By sector

Consumer Defensive leads at 66%; Industrials trails at 57%. The crowd knows some terrain and guesses at the rest. Hit rates cluster in the sectors people actually live in, where the average poster has a feel for the products and the headlines. The harder corners reward specialist knowledge most of the field does not have.

The Sector Tape
7d hit % · ranked
Chance · 61.5%
Consumer Defensive
65.9%Consumer Defensivewin65.9%calls1,030med ret-2.2%
Healthcare
65.3%Healthcarewin65.3%calls6,372med ret+0.4%
Consumer Cyclical
64.7%Consumer Cyclicalwin64.7%calls6,331med ret-1.2%
Real Estate
63.7%Real Estatewin63.7%calls405med ret-3.3%
Financial Services
62.2%Financial Serviceswin62.2%calls7,411med ret-0.6%
Communication Services
61.6%Communication Serviceswin61.6%calls10,303med ret-2.2%
Utilities
61.1%Utilitieswin61.1%calls965med ret-5.8%
Technology
61.0%Technologywin61.0%calls74,145med ret+0.1%
Energy
59.4%Energywin59.4%calls1,375med ret-5.7%
Basic Materials
59.0%Basic Materialswin59.0%calls1,046med ret-8.9%
Industrials
56.6%Industrialswin56.6%calls11,432med ret-6.7%
Win rate by sector, ranked: Consumer Defensive, 65.9% over 1030 calls; Healthcare, 65.3% over 6372 calls; Consumer Cyclical, 64.7% over 6331 calls; Real Estate, 63.7% over 405 calls; Financial Services, 62.2% over 7411 calls; Communication Services, 61.6% over 10303 calls; Utilities, 61.1% over 965 calls; Technology, 61.0% over 74145 calls; Energy, 59.4% over 1375 calls; Basic Materials, 59.0% over 1046 calls; Industrials, 56.6% over 11432 calls.

Stock calls only; covers 99.8% of resolved stock-call volume (the major-cap names).

03What Doesn'tthe negatives

Some of what the crowd believes about itself does not survive contact with the tape. Agreement, audience size and direction all look like they should matter. Measured against the target-before-stop rule, they mostly don't.

A call with a single account behind it hits 63% of the time. When 30+ separate accounts land on the same call inside a week, it is 68%. Agreement does not buy accuracy here. Crowding tends to arrive after a move rather than before it, so by the time a name is on everyone's timeline the easy part is usually gone.

The Agreement Curve
7d hit % by conviction
Chance · 61.5%
63%
1 (solo) agreewin62.5%calls4,182med ret-1.3%
59%
2–3 agreewin59.1%calls3,902med ret-1.2%
58%
4–6 agreewin57.7%calls3,602med ret-1.7%
64%
7–15 agreewin64.1%calls6,401med ret-1.0%
64%
16–30 agreewin64.2%calls7,863med ret+0.3%
68%
30+ agreewin67.7%calls16,870med ret+4.2%
1 (solo)
2–3
4–6
7–15
16–30
30+
Win rate by number of agreeing accounts: 1 (solo) agree, 62.5% over 4182 calls; 2–3 agree, 59.1% over 3902 calls; 4–6 agree, 57.7% over 3602 calls; 7–15 agree, 64.1% over 6401 calls; 16–30 agree, 64.2% over 7863 calls; 30+ agree, 67.7% over 16870 calls.

Calls grouped by how many distinct tracked accounts made the same call (ticker + direction) in the same week. Hit rates run flat to slightly lower as agreement rises, so a crowded call is not a safer one.

Crowded trades that paid

Each of these names drew twenty or more callers and still cleared a 67% hit rate — the rare case where a crowded trade was also a correct one. When the consensus formed around these tickers, it formed for a reason, and the tape paid it out.

Cohort
Decided
Hit %
Med. ret
NVDA logoNVDA
234
72.6%
+2.4%
GOOG logoGOOG
177
72.7%
+1.1%
MSFT logoMSFT
167
81.3%
+3.8%
AMZN logoAMZN
165
76.5%
-2.0%
TSLA logoTSLA
153
84.1%
+3.0%
Most-piled-into tickers (≥20 distinct callers, last 90d) whose hit rate cleared 67% — the same cut the rest of the site treats as a strong record. The 'n' column is distinct callers.

Crowded trades that didn't pay

The flip side: the names just as many people piled into, where the hit rate came in under 55% — well short of what chance alone reaches. Heavy attention pulls in momentum-chasers and latecomers as readily as it marks a real edge, and on these tickers the crowd mistook noise for conviction.

Cohort
Decided
Hit %
Med. ret
HOOD logoHOOD
112
50.0%
+5.2%
MRNA logoMRNA
97
48.9%
+11.3%
COHR logoCOHR
77
49.3%
-2.6%
DRAM logoDRAM
65
53.1%
+1.1%
SNOW logoSNOW
58
42.1%
+0.5%
Most-piled-into tickers (≥20 distinct callers, last 90d) whose hit rate came in under 55%, well short of what chance alone reaches. The 'n' column is distinct callers. The resolved window (Mar-May 2026) spans an April drawdown.

By audience size

Mega · 500k+ accounts grade 64%; Small · <5k accounts, 59%. A bigger audience does not buy a better record. Reach rewards confidence and posting volume more than it rewards being right, so the loudest accounts are not reliably the sharpest. Follower count measures how many people are listening, and almost nothing about whether they should be.

Cohort
Decided
Hit %
Mega · 500k+
14
64.3%
Large · 50–500k
105
62.7%
Mid · 5–50k
96
61.4%
Small · <5k
14
59.5%
Hit % here is each band's median caller hit rate, and Decided counts the callers in that band who have one. Calls that reached neither the target nor the stop inside 7 days are left out of every hit rate on this page rather than counted as losses.
05Pros vs JoesWhen the specialists fight the crowd

When a ticker’s specialists took the opposite side from the crowd, they were right more often, winning 136 of 204 weekly standoffs. A deep read on one name beat a broad take on all of them.

Pros
Score ≥ 70 on the ticker
136
standoffs won
VS
Joes
The crowd · everyone else
68
standoffs won
PROS 67%
33% JOES
The specialists win 67% when they break from the crowd.
verdict at 7 days · 204 standoffs

Standoffs by ticker

Ticker
Standoffs
Pros won
Joes won
ETH logoETH
8
6
2
TSLA logoTSLA
8
4
4
ORCL logoORCL
7
4
3
SPX logoSPX
7
3
4
NIO logoNIO
5
4
1
IWM logoIWM
5
3
2
BTC logoBTC
4
4
0
POET logoPOET
4
4
0
AAPL logoAAPL
4
3
1
+ 101 more tickers
152
101
51
Total
204
136
68

A standoff is one week a ticker’s specialists (per-ticker score ≥ 70 that day) and the crowd took opposite sides; the winner is whichever side’s calls returned more over the next 7 days. These are aggregate figures, with no individual names. Newer standoffs land in the next edition as they resolve.

06The RegimeSkill vs. the tide

When the S&P 500 rose, FinTwit's calls hit 62% of the time. When it fell, 61%. The gap is real but modest. Measured on target-before-stop, far less of this record is the market carrying the field than the returns alone suggest.

Riding the Tide
Hit rate vs. market direction
Chance · 61.5%
62%
Market rosewin62.4%calls91,615med ret+0.5%
61%
Market fellwin60.7%calls50,900med ret-2.3%
Market rose
+0.5% med
Market fell
-2.3% med
Win rate by market regime: Market rose, 62.4% over 91615 calls; Market fell, 60.7% over 50900 calls.

Hit rate split by whether the S&P 500 rose or fell over the call's 30-day holding window. The hit itself is a 7-day verdict.

See every graded account on the leaderboard →
07From the DeskKey findings · this edition

That’s the month, in six plain-English takeaways.

FinTwit Edge
— vs. a buy-and-hold S&P 500 over 30 days.
Beat the index
Only — of resolved calls beat SPY.
Bullish skew
— of calls are buys; the crowd rarely calls a top.
Strength in numbers
At peak agreement the hit rate is 67.7% — no better than a solo call.
Top sector
Consumer Defensive leads every sector at 65.9%.
Ranked field
229 accounts with a decided record this edition.

Cite this report

APA
SignalSnitch. (2026). The Accountability Desk: FinTwit vs. the Market (October 2026 edition). Retrieved from https://signalsnitch.io/state-of-fintwit/m/2026-10
Inline
Per SignalSnitch's Accountability Desk (signalsnitch.io/state-of-fintwit/m/2026-10), the median hit rate across 229 ranked finfluencers is 62.2%.

Free to republish with attribution under CC BY 4.0.

Use the data

Download the dataset
JSON · CORS-open · 1-hour cache · permanent URL
GET /api/stats →
Press & research inquiries
We share the underlying methodology, named-caller breakdowns, and quarterly refresh data on request.
press@signalsnitch.io →
Embed the grade for a named caller
OG-rendered hit-rate badge · sized & themed · iframe or do-follow anchor
View badge kit →

Other editions

September 2026
—% beat the S&P 500 · 242 ranked
Read →
August 2026
—% beat the S&P 500 · 257 ranked
Read →
July 2026
—% beat the S&P 500 · 226 ranked
Read →
June 2026
49% beat the S&P 500 · 218 ranked
Read →

About SignalSnitch

SignalSnitch grades the public market calls of social-media traders against actual price action and publishes the results as a leaderboard. The system is independent of brokerages and runs continuously; every figure on this page comes straight from the live dataset, with no hand-picking. Poise Through the Noise.

Aggregate figures only, across the ranked field. Educational, not investment advice. Frozen edition, computed from the live dataset at month close: October 2026.

© 2026 SignalSnitch · The Accountability Desk · Figures computed from the live dataset.
Home